Bill Memo: Better Bottle Bill

2 Tree: Substantial benefit rating


This bill amends the Environmental Conservation Law (ECL) by expanding the returnable container deposit scheme to include more beverage containers. The expansion would include bottled noncarbonated beverages, noncarbonated juices that are less than 100% fruit or vegetable juice, coffee, tea, carbonated fruit beverages, wine, liquor, distilled spirit coolers, and cider. This bill also increases the bottle deposit to 10 cents per container.




New York State’s Returnable Container Act (known as the “Bottle Bill”), which was last expanded in 2009, has proved effective at increasing recycling rates by providing ease of access and incentives for bottle and can returns.


Beverage containers of all sorts lie on the sides of the roads in our neighborhoods and on beaches, to the infamous garbage patches in our oceans – plastic pollution is a scourge on our environment.


This legislation both expands the types of containers eligible for a deposit under the bottle deposit law framework to include noncarbonated beverages, wine, liquor, and cider. The bill increases the refund value to 10 cents per container. Expanding the deposit program and increasing the refund value incentivizes consumers to return bottles to redemption centers for disposal, leading to an increase in recycling rates and making our environment and communities much cleaner.


In particular, the legislation expands the law’s application to a wider variety of glass containers, which will have immense benefits in increasing glass recycling rates and assisting curbside recycling programs. Municipal recycling programs struggle with glass contaminating their recycling streams because when glass breaks in the single stream recycling process it contaminates the rest of the materials and impacts the recyclability of the stream.


Download PDF

Environmental Advocates NY Bill Rating: Substantial Benefit

Memo #: 20